Buy PULP FICTION here!


HOME!
the REVIEWS Folder: complete a to z software, hardware and dvd-rom reviews

NEWS

REVIEWS

RESOURCES

TECHNICAL

FORUMS

SITE INFORMATION

 

Search The DVD File

Click here for search tips 

AARDNARK'S SITE GUIDE

   


   

     Trainspotting

  • 1994 / 94 Minutes / Color / Rated R
  • Single-Sided Disc: 2.35:1 Widescreen Presentation (Not Enhanced for 16x9
  • Keepcase
Alliance Release
  • English Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround / French Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround
  • English Subtitles
  • Special Features: Interactive Menus / Scene Access / 22-Minute Making Feature with Filmmaker Interview and Deleted Scenes / Theatrical Trailer
  • $24.95 est. ($29.95 Canadian)

    Buena Vista Release

  • English Dolby Digital 5.1 Surround / English Dolby Digital 2.0 Surround
  • English Subtitles
  • Special Features: Interactive Menus / Scene Access / Theatrical Trailer
  • $29.95

Reviewed by Peter M. Bracke for The DVD File. This review first posted on January 11th, 1999.

To submit your own review, please use the handy Review Submittal Form.


Sample internal thoughts of a (heroin) addict:

The truth is i'm a bAd person. But that's gonnA change. i'm going to change.This is the last of That sort o thiinG. (HEROIN) Now I'm cleaning up and i'M going straight and choosing LIFe. (heroin) I'm loking foreward and to it already...I'm gonna be just like U. (smack) The job, the family, the fucking BiG tele(TV)ision...the washing m@chine, the car, the compact disc, the elecrical tin opener. heroin Good Health, low cholesterøl, dental in$urance, mortage, (Her/  staRter hoome,  /oin) leisure suite, designeer luggage, 3-piece suit, D.I.Y., (HeroiN) game shows, 9 to 5, good at golf, washinG the car, cleaning me loafers, fucking Christmas trees, indeXXX pension, (heroin) tax exemptions, cleaninG gutTers, getting by, looking ahead, the day you die...

  

Trainspotting is the shit, great movie, see it now.

    

Video

(Editor's Note: Due to a licensing arrangement made before Miramax was bought by Disney, Alliance has the Canadian distribution rights to Miramax titles on DVD. Hence, there are two versions available in Region 1.)

Both the Alliance and Buena Vista releases of Trainspotting contain the same 1.85:1 letterboxed transfer, which is non-anamorphic. Overall, the transfer is good, with a strong saturation of color a deep black level. The film element used does contain some speckles and nicks, and there is some grain apparent throughout However, for a low-budget indie production, this looks very good, and only the lack of 16x9 enhancement is a major detriment to the image. A solid transfer if not great.

Sound

The Dolby Digital 5.1 mixes are audibly identical. I couldn't tell any difference between the two, and both offered a pleasing if somewhat subdued surround sound experience. The ambient surrounds are used sparingly, though the music presentation is forceful. Given that Trainspotting is such a trippy film, a more aggressive and experimental soundtrack would seem appropriate, but overall it is not that dynamic. Frequency range, bass response and dialogue are all well recorded and rendered, just not exceptional. But, like the image, it is certainly good enough

Supplements

Well, no big surprise, the Buena Vista version doesn't quite make the cut in the extras department. Both share a Theatrical Trailer and English subtitles, though the Alliance version also contains a nice 22-minute mini-documentary that features interviews with Director Danny Boyle and Producer Scott MacDonald, as well as some deleted scenes. There is no reason Buena Vista couldn't have included this in the U.S. version, but they just continue to mystify. However, while both versions state that a Glossary of Trainspotting Terms is included on the disc, I couldn't find it anyhere on either version. Go figure.

Summary

In terms of features and price, the Alliance version wins out of the U.S. Buena Vista release. Although the image and sound quality is the same, the added features are a nice bonus, and perhaps Buena Vista could learn a thing or two from Alliance. Go Canadian if you can.

(Note: If you are interested in purchasing either version of this disc, please visit DVDepot, a great Canadian-based Region 1 retailer. They ship throughout Region 1.)

Ratings (out of five stars and in relationship to original age of the picture/sound elements):

Alliance Version:

Picture: ***1/2
Sound: ****
Supplements: ***1/2
Price/Value: ***1/2

Buena Vista Version:

Picture: ***1/2
Sound: ****
Supplements: **
Price/Value: **1/2

* = not worthy of a DIVX disc; ** = below par; *** = good; **** = excellent; ***** = kill your mother to get a copy


Equipment List: Pioneer VSX-D3S Dolby Digital Reciever / Sony DVP-3000 Digital Versatile Disc Player / Sony 32" V Chassis Trinitron TV with Digital Comb Filter and S-Video / Pioneer CLD-704 LaserDisc Player / Pioneer DVL-700 LD-DVD Player


This Site Maintained by Peter M. Bracke . Graphics copyright ®1998 redesign. All illustrations by Tom Crawford, copyright ®1998
This site is hosted by TABNet and is best viewed with 256 colors and font sizes set to 12-point. on Macs and 10-point on PCs.