NETFLIX.COM - Click Here To Rent And Buy DVDs!
Support The DVD File and visit our sponsor  


HOME!
the REVIEWS Folder: complete a to z software, hardware and dvd-rom reviews

NEWS

REVIEWS

RESOURCES

TECHNICAL

FORUMS

SITE INFORMATION

Search The DVD File

Click here for search tips 

AARDNARK'S SITE GUIDE

   

THE SEVEN SAMURAI box cover art

     The Seven Samurai

  • A Criterion Collection Release
  • 1954/204 min/Black and White/Not Rated
  • Dual-Layer Disc: Original 1.33:1 Aspect Ratio (not anamorphic)
  • Japanese Dolby Digital 2.0 Mono
  • English Subtitles
  • Features: Interactive Menus / Scene Access / U.S. Theatrical Trailer / Feature-length screen-specific audio commentary by Japanese film expert Michael Jeck / Featurette on the restoration process
  • Keepcase
  • List Price: $39.95

        Click HERE for more information about this film


Reviewed by Edward Owens for The DVD File. This review first posted on December 3rd, 1998

To submit your own review, please use the handy Review Submittal Form.


The cinematic arts have lost two of its greatest practitioners just within the last year. The first to pass was the formidable Toshiro Mifune, who died in early December of 1997. Mifune was considered by many to be Japan's leading actor, and by many more to be one of the world's greatest. The second passing was that of Mifune's longtime friend and collaborator Akira Kurosawa. During Kurosawa's long and prolific career, he delivered a collection of films that have personified and influenced Hollywood films more Hollywood's own. Considering the loss of both men, it is fitting that The Seven Samurai, the epic high point of both men's careers, would make its best showing ever in a newly restored DVD edition from Criterion.  

The Japanese made The Seven Samurai, looks and sound like a prototypical Hollywood western--a group of farmers, threatened by a nomadic band of thieves, decide to hire wandering samurai to protect them. The samurai eventually collected by the villagers represent a wide variety of ideologies, personalities and characters, all united in defending the villagers: the wise and experienced Shimada (Takashi Shimura), who becomes the group's tactical and emotional leader; the manic and foolhardy Kikuchiyo (Mifune, in his seventh and best known Kurosawa film); the young and impressionable Katsushiro (Isao Kimura); and others. As the samurai gather in the village, they also recruit the farmers, teaching them to fight and preparing for the epic battle ahead.  

The fact that a description of The Seven Samurai's story line sounds like a generic summary of a cliché plot is indicative of just how influential the film has been since its Japanese premiere in 1954. Hollywood has copied it once (The Magnificent Seven with Yul Brenner) and imitated it endlessly. The film is a superb study in character and motivation with beautifully framed images and seamlessly choreographed fight scenes, both of which hold an incredible power. The image of Yohei's gnarled hand collecting spilled rice from the floor sticks just as firmly in the mind as Kikuchiyo's valiant (and arrogant) stand against onrushing horsemen. Perhaps the film's greatest accomplishment is its ability to sustain interest throughout its nearly three and a half hour length (the film was originally released in the US in a 140 min cut, but was restored to its original length in the late 80‚s). The film never drags and even holds up to multiple viewings.  

Criterion's DVD edition of The Seven Samurai is superb in every respect. The picture has been heavily restored, and looks better than ever. The black and white picture exhibits strong detail, with crisp edges and good gray scale. Shadow detail is strongly delineated and contrast is high. The image occasionally shimmers as a result of excessive aging of the original elements, but overall the restoration is by far the best presentation the film has received on any medium (to include Criterion's excellent laserdisc edition). Further, the film is presented uninterrupted, more than reason enough to add this particular version to anyone's collection.  

The Japanese soundtrack is undistinguished mono similar to the previous laser release. However, restoration work has also been done on the soundtrack--and the difference is audible. The soundtrack has been cleaned up considerably by adjusting level consistency and replacing audio dropouts which had resulted from lost or damaged materials. The result is a solid and pleasing (even if monaural) music and effects track to accompany a visually stunning film.  

The film is supplemented by the U.S. theatrical trailer, running screen-specific audio commentary, and a five-minute featurette on the restoration process. The trailer should be avoided by anyone who hasn't seen the film, as it reveals integral plot developments. The commentary is by noted Japanese film historian Michael Jeck. Jeck's commentary is interesting not only for the many insights he provides into Kurosawa's work in general and this film in particular, but also for the comments regarding Japanese culture, an integral part of the film's story. Jeck's comments are well worth the extra time it takes to listen. The featurette detailing the restoration process consists mostly of a series of comparison shots between the film prior to its restoration and the film after the work has been done. The comparison provides the viewer with a better understanding of the work that went into improving the print, as well as the general plight of most older films.  

Toshiro Mifune has said that he was proud of nothing he had done other than with Kurosawa. Criterion's DVD edition of The Seven Samurai does the memory of both men proud.

Ratings (out of five stars and in relationship to original age of the picture/sound elements):

Picture: ***1/2
Sound: ***
Supplements: ***1/2
Price/Value: ****

* = not worthy of a DIVX disc; ** = below par; *** = good; **** = excellent; ***** = kill your mother to get a copy

NetFlix - The Easiest Way To Rent Or Buy A DVD!


Equipment List: Pioneer DVD-Laserdisc Combo Player / Panasonic DVD Player / 34" ProScan 16x9 Television / Pioneer Receiver with Polk Audio Speakers / Pioneer AC-3 Decoder


This Site Maintained by Peter M. Bracke . Graphics copyright ®1998 redesign. All illustrations by Tom Crawford, copyright ®1998
This site is hosted by TABNet and is best viewed with 256 colors and font sizes set to 12-point. on Macs and 10-point on PCs.