American Pie
Universal Studios Home Video / 1999 / 96 Minutes / Not Rated
Street date: December 21, 1999

I've repeatedly heard American Pie being referred to as "A Porky's for the 90s," but after now having seen both, Porkys makes American Pie look like Woody Allen! That's not to say that American Pie could be considered an intellectual film that rivals Shakespeare, but it's a damn funny movie that has something real and true to say about the adolescent experience. It also succeeds in often completely throwing the viewer off-guard with a brand of visual comedy that is quite unique and very 90's.

Much of the Porky's comparison stems directly from the plot, that follows four high school friends and their quest to get laid. While each of them are seemingly of different social backgrounds and popularity, none of them have "done the deed." Oz (Chris Kline) is a star athlete whose transparent attempts at being romantic are immediately detected by the women he targets, while Kevin (Thomas Ian Nicholas) has a girlfriend, but has yet to get to the shuttle launch stage with her. Out of the other two, Finch (Eddie Kaye Thomas) is the most mysterious of the group. His plan, if it could be called that, is to arouse enough curiosity out of the girls at school to simply arouse! And finally we get to Jim (Jason Biggs), whose total lack of experience eventually drives him to baked goods...

On the female side, Tara Reid is Kevin's girlfriend Vicky, who wants everything to be 100% for that magical first time. Shannon Elizabeth brings considerable assets to the role of the Czechoslovakian exchange hottie, Nadia. And one of my absolute favorite actresses of late, Natasha Lyonne, has some of the movies funniest moments as Jessica, the girl whose got all the answers and influence. Last but not least on my list is Alyson Hannigan, from Buffy the Vampire Slayer, who is impressive as the band geek Michelle. Not only is she really cute to watch, she has the movie's funniest line, hands down.

One of the joys of watching American Pie for me was how much it brought back the high school experience. I can distinctly remember there being nothing else more important than getting just a little bit. (Editor: Not that you'd know, snicker snicker.) That may be a crass assessment of my high school days, but that's how it was. I doubt any other guy would (truthfully) be able to plea to other intentions during those years. However, I also can't remember there being that many virgins by senior year as the film depicts. Maybe that was just the freewheeling, decadent late 80s, but you'd never be able to find four guys at my high school that hung around together without at least one of them at one point having had been able to "double click the mouse."

I know that American Pie was a huge hit in theaters, but I think it will go on to even bigger success on video. This is the type of film that video was made for. I know I'm looking forward to watching it again because it's the only movie I've seen recently that actually made me throw my hands over my face because I couldn't believe what I was actually seeing. That's rare for me, and I think that may be the highest compliment I could pay American Pie. It truly shocked me!

Special mention must be made that American Pie is being presented in separate R-rated and Unrated DVD versions. Our review is for the Unrated edition, which offers up more pie-lovin' and thus will undoubtedly end up being the preferred version. Funny thing is, I know that the reason to offer both versions is because stores like Blockbuster won't carry any unrated stuff, but exactly who would be offended by the unrated version that would still really get into the R-rated edition? Can you imagine someone saying "I would have enjoyed him making love to the pie if it only weren't so graphic...Grandma's having nightmares!"?

Video: How Does The Disc Look?

The overall quality of this anamorphic widescreen DVD is generally excellent. Colors are bold and vibrant with no bleeding or oversaturation. The amount of detail possible with the extra resolution provided by the anamorphic transfer is wonderful, with a crisp look and absolutely no over enhancement. The print used was of the highest quality, with no defects to mar the image such as dirt or scratches.

While the black level on the disc is absolutely spot on, some of the interior scenes, like the party early on, seem to come off a bit too dark. This directly affects the shadow detail, which at times can be rather undefined and lacking. Other than that, there are plenty of great things to about this image. Although it's not perfect, it is quite above average.

Audio: How Does the Disc Sound?

The English Dolby Digital 5.1 track is hit and miss, but in the end comes out a bit better than most comedies. Dialog is clear and free, without masking or distortion, and surround use is there but it's just really quiet. That is one step above normal comedy soundtracks, which virtually ignore the surrounds. There's not much bass for anyone to hear, mostly in a few of the songs. Again, this movie is so funny that you'll never notice the soundtrack because you'll be laughing really hard the whole time.

A French Dolby 2.0 surround track is included along with English Captions and Spanish subtitles.

Supplements: What Goodies Are There?

Universal has released American Pie as yet another of their Collector's Edition series. Here's what goodies you get:

Feature Commentary is a screen-specific audio commentary track with director Paul Weitz, his brother and producer Chris Weitz, writer Adam Herz and cast members Jason Biggs, Eddie Kaye Thomas, and Seann William Scott. I usually find commentaries where there are multiple participants to be occasionally confusing on the order of who's speaking. This one is no exception, but does redeem itself by being both funny and informative. This is the place where you'll get to learn all about "man chowder." Figure that one out.

The Universal-produced Spotlight On Location is more in line with a making-of featurette than a full-blown documentary. This one, though, is a notch above the norm, interspersing interviews with the cast and crew with funny clips from the movie. The interview portions contain cast musings on the ribald subject matter as well as the actors own experiences. It's every bit as R-rated as the film and as such seems to be made with this DVD in mind. I can't imaging them using this for promotion on the WB!

The Outtakes offer up a small variety of alternate takes and improv moments. Some of these are very funny, and it's a shame that the offering is so short. Music Highlights, another Universal hallmark, gives you direct access to 22 of the film's songs. Unfortunately, they are presented within the film and not as isolated songs.

The promotional angle of the disc includes the Universal Soundtrack Presentation, a commercial for the American Pie soundtrack, as well as a music video by Tonic for their song "You Wanted More." The American Pie Theatrical Trailer is included along with the trailers for the new Andy Kaufman biopic Man in the Moon and coma-inducing Snow Falling on Cedars, accessible through the Universal Showcase selection. All three of these trailers are presented in non-anamorphic widescreen with Dolby Digital 5.1 sound, a first for Universal. Even more trailers can be found in the Recommendations section. There you'll find previews for The Blues Brothers, Animal House and American Graffiti.

Finalizing the disc are Universal's standard Cast & Filmmakers bios and Production Notes. One last thing included here and on the new Fast Times at Ridgemont High DVD is a listing for Classic Quotes. This gives you instant access to 20 six-month old classic lines from American Pie. Unfortunately, the line that I think is the best of the movie is not even included. I call shenanigans!

DVD-ROM Exclusives: What do you get when you pop the disc in your PC?

Pop in the disc and you're presented with a custom American Pie interface, embedded with weblinks to various Universal sites and the official American Pie portal, plus a bonus Behind-the-Scenes feature exclusive to the ROM side. It's a realtively short few minutes of additional interviews, and you can watch it in a rather-smallish video window.

Parting Thoughts

This movie is definitely not for all tastes. If you like your comedy a little more raunchy than most, American Pie will "fill you up" (don't you just love those little critic sound bites?) The extras on this disc are worthy of the Universal Collector's Edition banner and at a price below the norm for them, so it is even more of a bargain. I'll be recommending this one to all my friends, and that includes you, my DVD compatriots!

» Buy It: Click for best price

» Discuss: Weigh in at the forum

» Spin It: More 'American Pie'

4 of 5
4 of 5
3.5 of 5
4 of 5

DISC FEATURES

Specifications
- DVD-Video
- Dual-Layer Disc
- Region 1
- InterActual Enhanced

Aspect Ratio(s):
- 1.85:1 Anamorphic Widescreen

Dolby Digital Formats:
- English 5.1 Surround
- French 2.0 Surround

DTS Formats:
- None

PCM Formats:
- None

Subtitles/Captions:
- English Captions
- Spanish Subtitles

Standard Features:
- Interactive menus
- Scene access

Supplements:
- Screen-specific audio commentary
- Making-of featurette
- Outtakes
- Production notes
- Filmographies
- Theatrical trailers

InterActual DVD-ROM Features:
- Behind-the-scenes feature
- Weblinks

List Price:
- $19.95